Picking the right streaming service feels like shopping in an endless aisle. You want great shows, fair price, and apps that actually work on your TV. This streaming service comparison breaks down the major players—Netflix, Disney+, Hulu, Amazon Prime Video, HBO Max (Max), Peacock and Paramount+—so you can decide without drowning in trial subscriptions. I’ll explain what matters: price, catalog, device support, picture quality, and how each fits different viewing habits. From what I’ve seen, there’s no single winner for everyone—so I’ll help you find the best fit for your needs.
How I evaluated streaming services
I compared services using several consistent criteria: price tiers, content library, exclusive originals, device support, simultaneous streams, video quality (HD/4K/HDR), and extras like live TV or sports. I tested apps on smart TVs, phones, and web browsers, and reviewed recent catalog changes. Real-world testing matters—some platforms are flawless on a phone but glitchy on older smart TVs. In my experience, the small details (like profile limits or download support) often decide the day-to-day satisfaction.
At-a-glance comparison table
Quick reference: prices and features vary by region and change over time. Prices listed are approximate and indicate typical US plans as of 2025.
| Service | Typical Price | Free Trial | 4K/HDR | Simultaneous Streams | Notable Originals |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Netflix | $9.99–$19.99 | Rare/promotions | Yes (higher tiers) | 1–4 (tiered) | Stranger Things, The Crown |
| Disney+ | $7.99–$13.99 | Occasional promos | Yes (select titles) | 4 | Mandalorian, MCU series |
| Hulu | $7.99–$79.99 (with Live) | Often for new users | Limited | 2–4 (with add-ons) | The Handmaid’s Tale |
| Amazon Prime Video | Included with Prime $14.99/mo | No (Prime trial exists) | Yes | 3 | The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel, Rings of Power |
| Max (HBO) | $9.99–$15.99 | Limited promos | Yes | 3–4 | Succession, Euphoria |
| Peacock | Free–$11.99 | Often for premium | Limited | 3 | Yellowstone (streaming rights), Originals |
| Paramount+ | $4.99–$11.99 | Occasional | Limited | 2–4 | Star Trek series, NFL highlights |
Key factors to consider (and why they matter)
1. Catalog: What you actually watch
Big catalogs don’t always help. I’ve found narrower libraries with strong originals often beat huge but shallow catalogs. If you love prestige dramas, HBO/Max and Netflix are heavy hitters. For family and franchise content, Disney+ is the clear leader.
2. Price vs. value
Cheap plans can be worth it if the content matches your taste. Free ad-supported tiers (Peacock, Paramount+, Hulu) can save serious cash if you tolerate ads. If you stream in 4K often, paying for a higher tier (Netflix, Disney+, Prime Video) can be justified.
3. Video quality and device support
4K and HDR are great—until your TV or internet can’t handle it. Check supported devices: some platforms perform poorly on older smart TV operating systems. From what I’ve seen, Amazon Prime Video and Netflix have the broadest device compatibility.
4. Simultaneous streams and profiles
Households matter. If everyone streams shows at once, a service with 3–4 simultaneous streams or family plan is essential. Profiles and parental controls are also a real-world convenience for families.
5. Live TV, sports and extras
Need local channels or live sports? Hulu + Live TV (and add-ons on other platforms) can replace cable for many. For NFL or major sports, check league-specific rights—Paramount+ and Peacock carry certain events, while Max has exclusive HBO sports documentaries.
Who should pick which service
Best for binge-watchers
Netflix—if you love serialized dramas and constant new originals. Pricey at the top tier, but the ongoing pipeline is useful if you watch a lot.
Best for families and franchises
Disney+—Marvel, Star Wars, Pixar, and family-friendly animated content. Also strong for parents who want easy kids’ profiles.
Best for prestige and adult drama
Max (HBO)—compact library but high-quality originals. Great if you want fewer, higher-impact shows.
Best for shoppers and Prime users
Prime Video—if you already pay for Amazon Prime, you get a solid streaming library plus frequent movie rentals and live events.
Best budget option
Peacock or ad-supported tiers—good for casual viewers who don’t need the latest exclusive drama.
Real-world examples and scenarios
- Young couple with shared tastes: Netflix + Disney+ combo covers most bases—original dramas and family movies.
- Large family with kids: Disney+ plus a budget plan like Peacock free tier; add Netflix if you want more adult content.
- Sports fan: Consider Paramount+ (certain football rights) and Peacock for Premier League clips—then add a sports-focused cable replacement if needed.
- Single viewer who watches less: Pick one service that matches your preferred genre—saves money and avoids churn.
Tips to save money
- Rotate subscriptions by month based on releases you want to watch.
- Share family plans where allowed—be mindful of terms of service.
- Use bundled deals (e.g., streaming bundles or carrier promotions).
- Try ad-supported tiers and upgrade only if the ad burden is too high.
Feature checklist before you subscribe
- Does the service support your TV and streaming devices?
- Are must-watch titles available there (check catalogs)?
- How many simultaneous streams and profiles are included?
- Is 4K/HDR available for the content you want?
- Does the price align with how often you’ll use it?
Quick verdicts
Netflix for originals and variety. Disney+ for franchises and families. Max for high-quality drama. Prime Video for Prime members. Peacock and Paramount+ for budget-conscious viewers or niche sports/franchise fans.
Helpful resources
For the latest company-specific details check official sites and reference pages. Subscription details and catalogs change often.
Summary and next steps
Start by listing the shows and genres you care about. Match that list against the catalogs above, weigh price and device compatibility, and consider rotating subscriptions around big releases. If you want my short take: pick one primary paid service that matches your taste, add a cheap ad-supported second service for variety, and swap when new must-watch seasons arrive. Happy streaming—may your buffers be few and your picture crisp.